IndiaP2P Blog

Responsible content on personal finance & economics that makes you smarter about money.

Mental Accounting & Why you may be thinking about money all wrong.


Blog Image

The different values we as people put on the same amount of money based on subjective or emotional criteria is our personal mental accounting. This type of accounting may seem useful or in the very least harmless but it is simply bad for us.

Mental Accounting has been studied and popularised by behavioral economist Richard Thaler. He says that we tend to ‘mentally classify’ money even though money is just money (i.e. its fungible), leading to both irrational spending and irrational investments.

For most of us, money received unexpectedly is always considered more spendable or put in the ‘can afford to risk’ category. In reality, money categorised as ‘can afford to risk’ and money categorised otherwise/for safekeeping/monthly budget etc. should be treated the with the same diligence.

For example: I had planned to wait until the end of the year to buy new clothes because I already have too many, but since I received some money as a Diwali bonus, I feel free to do it now.  Now, the logic for not spending on clothes remains intact but since I treat bonus money differently and not as regular money, I end up making an irrational spending decision.

Mental accounting also causes us to look at identical spends as being different. Consider this scenario which was tested on respondents under a study conducted by Princeton University -
Imagine you just arrived at a cinema and as you reach into your pocket to pull out the Rs 200 ticket you purchased in advance, you discover that it’s missing. Would you spend over another Rs. 200 to see the movie?
Compare that to a second scenario in which you did not buy the ticket in advance, but when you arrive at the cinema, you discover you lost a Rs. 200 note. Would you still buy a movie ticket?”

Having just read nearly an entire article on mental accounting, you no doubt realise that each scenario has the same outcome: a loss of Rs. 200 i.e. it really does not matter (financially speaking) whether you watch the movie or not!

The bottom line being, whether we like to believe it or not, money is money. It’s not salary money or cashback money or Rakhi money. It is all the same thing and should be thought of as such. A simple way to correct mental accounting is to think of your money minus any categorisations.


Author: Neha Juneja

Other Blogs

Impact of rising interest rates on your investments



Inflation has risen across the globe to become a pain point for policymakers who grapple with rising prices and faltering economic growth. Things seemingly turned worrisome when the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) raised the repo rate by 40 basis points on May 4 and again on June 6.  With the growing interest rates, should investors like you need to worry? What should be your strategy towards investment during such times? Let’s find out.   First, let us revisit the connection between inflation, interest rate, bond yields etc.   Inflation and interest rates are directionally related, i.e. they tend to move along the same trend but with some lag. RBI and other central banks desire positive but manageable inflation rates. A negative inflation rate or deflation means degrowth in the economy because with rapidly decreasing prices, consumers tend to pause/postpone their spends leading to slowdown in economic activity.   Fundamentally, the supply and demand...


What is the tax rate on my investment? - June 2022



Many of us are unprepared for the tax payouts applicable to our investments and forget to factor them in.    Here's a ready reckoner to help you estimate your 'post-tax returns' and compare investment options.   Tax Rates on Your Investments   Tax Type  Short Term Gains  Long Term Gains Equity mutual fund  Post-tax earnings are added to your income and taxed as per your individual tax slab. 15% + 4% cess 10% + 4% cess (LTCG >1 year) Debt mutual fund  Post-tax earnings are added to your income and taxed as per your individual tax slab. At the tax slab rate of the individual  20% + 4% cess with indexation (LTCG >3 year) Equity  Post-tax earnings are added to your income and taxed as per your individual tax slab. 15%  10% over and above Rs. 1 lakh without indexation (LTCG >1 year) Debt Listed At the tax slab rate of the...


How does IndiaP2P offer such high returns with low risk?



How does IndiaP2P offer such high returns with low risk?   IndiaP2P’s first-of-its-kind return-risk profile is the result of a unique yet large arbitrage opportunity that exists in the debt markets of emerging economies such as India.   First, let’s recap how the equity and debt markets differ. While retail investors have had access to equity investments for long, debt has been gaining in popularity over the last decade.   Read on…   We all have come across the terms debt and equity quite often. And while we may use them in the same breath, they are actually quite different. Equity is the process of raising capital by selling a portion of shares from the business.  For example, you receive a certain amount of capital infusion in your company in the form of equity. This means that you don't have to repay the amount later. However, the investor receives a portion of shares. Hence, they will receive profits in sync with their...


Featured In

Have more questions? Click here to schedule a quick call with our investments team


Start Investing